Most DTC brands pay full price to win a first order, and then most of those customers never come back. Ecommerce customer retention helps turn one-time buyers into repeat buyers without another round of ads.
A Beauchamp Sullivan & Co. analysis of more than 156,000 DTC customers, reported in Shopify’s 2026 retention guide, found an average repeat purchase rate of 18.8%. In other words, about 81% of customers never place a second order.
For DTC brands that want to grow without acquiring new customers for every order, closing that gap is one of the biggest growth opportunities. This guide explains how to measure retention, what a healthy repeat rate looks like, and which strategies tend to move it.
What is ecommerce customer retention?
Ecommerce customer retention is the work of getting existing customers to buy again. Brands track it with three numbers: repeat purchase rate (the share of customers who order more than once), customer retention rate (how many customers stay active over a period), and churn (the share who stop buying).
Retention rate has a standard formula:
E = Customers at the end of the period
N = New customers acquired during the period
S = Customers at the start of the period
Say you start a quarter with 1,000 customers, win 300 new ones, and end with 1,100. Your retention rate is (1,100 − 300) ÷ 1,000 × 100 = 80%.
Repeat purchase rate answers a different question: what share of all customers have ordered more than once? Pick a time window for both numbers, because a 90-day figure and a 12-month figure aren’t comparable.
What is a good repeat purchase rate for ecommerce?
There’s no single good number. In the Beauchamp Sullivan & Co. analysis of more than 156,000 DTC customers, the average repeat purchase rate was 18.8%. Consumable brands ran 22% to 44%, fashion 10% to 17%, and durables and home goods 7% to 18%. Compare yourself to your category, not the average.
| Category | Repeat Purchase Rate | Why It Differs |
|---|---|---|
| Consumables | 22% to 44% | The product itself creates the reason to reorder |
| Fashion | 10% to 17% | Purchases are driven by season and taste |
| Durables and home goods | 7% to 18% | Few people replace a couch every quarter |
Other sources cite higher averages. Shopify’s guide mentions a 2024 Sprinklr study with an ecommerce retention rate of about 38%, but it warns that any average depends on what you sell and how long you measure. Its advice is to pick a window that matches your normal reorder cycle and compare like-for-like cohorts.
Key takeaway: A coffee brand and a mattress brand shouldn’t share a retention target. Measure against your own category and your own past cohorts.
Which ecommerce customer retention strategies work best for DTC brands?
The strategies that tend to move repeat purchases are post-purchase email and SMS flows, loyalty programs with easy redemption, and win-back messages timed to when customers normally reorder. Start with the one that fixes your biggest drop-off, which is usually the gap between the first and second order.
How do email and SMS flows support retention?
Klaviyo’s 2026 email benchmarks, based on data from more than 183,000 of its customers, found that automated flows generate nearly 41% of email revenue from only 5.3% of sends. Revenue per recipient runs nearly 18 times higher than for campaigns. Klaviyo sells email software, so treat the numbers as a strong signal from its own customer base, not a universal average.
One detail matters for retention work. Nearly 48% of flow revenue comes from new buyers, because welcome, browse and abandoned-cart flows convert first purchases. As a result, a high flow share doesn’t prove your repeat business is healthy.
Build retention flows on purpose:
- Post-purchase: Usage tips or setup help that make the first order worth the money.
- Second-order nudge: A relevant product suggestion timed to when similar customers reorder.
- Replenishment reminder: For consumables, a message based on how long one unit lasts.
- Win-back: Triggered when a customer passes their usual reorder window without buying.
- VIP early access: A thank-you for your top spenders.
Time each flow to your own data. Time to second purchase, the typical gap between a customer’s first and second order, tells you when to send.
Lapsed customers don’t have to be reached by email alone. Paid social retargeting can use the same segments, which helps when someone stops opening your messages.
Do loyalty programs increase repeat purchases?
Often, yes, but the evidence comes from people who already joined. In Deloitte’s 2025 survey of 5,564 US loyalty program members, 72% said programs make them more likely to spend with their preferred brand and 56% said they increase spending because of it. The questions focused on each respondent’s favorite brand loyalty program, so the results shouldn’t be generalized to every loyalty program.
Participation is the weak point. Consumers in the survey enrolled in eight programs on average but actively used five, and 40% admitted they sometimes forget to redeem rewards.
So design for use, not enrollment. Make redemption one click, reward the behavior you want (a second order, a review, a referral), and set point thresholds against your margin and your normal reorder cycle.
How does retention change what you can spend on acquisition?
Retention raises customer lifetime value (LTV), the profit a customer brings over time, which helps determine how much a brand can afford to spend on customer acquisition cost (CAC). A customer who looks unprofitable after one order can pay back once repeat orders count.
Here’s an illustrative example with made-up numbers:
| Scenario | Orders per Customer | Gross Profit per Order | LTV | CAC | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before retention work | 1.5 | $24 | $36 | $50 | Loses $14 per customer |
| After retention work | 2.5 | $24 | $60 | $50 | Earns $10 per customer |
The gross profit assumes a $60 order and a 40% margin. There’s no universal ratio that works for every brand, because payback time and cash flow matter too. Still, the pattern holds: retention gives acquisition room to work.
Bringing in new customers is only part of the growth equation. The ecommerce lead generation tactics that attract first-time buyers work best when a retention plan is already in place.
How do you measure ecommerce customer retention?
Track repeat purchase rate, retention rate, time to second order, and the revenue split between new and returning customers by cohort. Use one time window consistently. Cohorts, which group customers by the month of their first order, show whether retention is improving even while total sales grow.
A short list of numbers covers most decisions:
- Repeat purchase rate: Shows whether first-time buyers become second-time buyers.
- Time to second order: Tells you when to send replenishment or second-order messages.
- New vs. returning revenue: Shows how much growth depends on constant acquisition.
- RFM (recency, frequency, monetary value): Sorts customers by how recently they bought, how often, and how much they spend, so you can pick who to reward and who to win back.
Shopify’s Customers reports include returning customer rate, new vs. returning customer sales, cohort analysis and an RFM report. Brands on other platforms can build the same views from order exports.
What mistakes hurt ecommerce customer retention?
Most retention problems come from measuring the wrong thing or applying the right tactic to the wrong customer:
- Using one benchmark for every category: A fashion brand compared with a food brand will always look weak.
- Counting new buyers in retention: The formula subtracts new customers for a reason. Leave them in and a good acquisition month reads as good retention.
- Treating all flows as retention: Almost half of flow revenue comes from new buyers, so split reports by new and returning.
- Discounting second orders for customers who’d reorder anyway: Test the offer against a control group before you give margin away.
- Making rewards hard to use: Forty percent of loyalty members sometimes forget to redeem their rewards, so make redemption simple and easy to access.
Where should a DTC brand start with ecommerce customer retention?
Start with the data you already have and work in this order:
- Calculate your repeat purchase rate and retention rate for one fixed window.
- Compare them with the range for your category.
- Find your typical time to second order.
- Build one post-purchase flow and one win-back flow around that timing.
- Add a loyalty or VIP program only after the flows work, and make redemption easy.
Most ecommerce brands can finish the first three steps with order data they already have. Ecommerce customer retention rewards patience and clean measurement. Pick one metric, one window and one flow to improve, then add the next piece when the last one pays back.
